Catherynne Valente: A More Satisfying Scheherazade

Illustrations by the talented and versatile Michael Kaluta

Illustrations by the talented and versatile Michael Kaluta

Review originally posted at Fantasy Literature.

In the Night Garden is essentially Arabian Nights, if Scheherazade had been a feminist literary critic with a working knowledge of world mythology and a wicked sense of irony.  Certainly, this Scheherazade wouldn’t have ended up marrying the Sultan who put his first 1,000 wives to the death.

It starts with a young girl with dark tattoos around her eyes: tiny, black letters spelling out hundreds of fairy tales.  A young prince becomes obsessed with the girl’s stories, and very soon the reader and the young prince are both sitting in rapt silence in the night garden, listening.  For maybe five pages, you feel you’re in comfortable, predictable territory.  The tattooed girls tells of a prince who runs away from home and discovers a witch’s hut in the woods.  Ah, you think, if he doesn’t watch his mouth he’ll be set three impossible tasks.  Or he’ll be transformed into a pig, or a beast, or wind up living in an enchanted castle waiting for his true love to see past his ugliness and marry him.  But the rules are different in the night garden.  Instead, the witch woman emerges, horribly scarred, and tells the prince her story.  The nesting stories continue, each one more unearthly and brilliant and unpredictable than the last.

Like Byatt’s The Djinn in the Nightingale’s Eye, In the Night Garden is both a loving homage to fairy tales, and a gleeful overturning of the tired tropes and values they represent.  Fairy tales, as we all know, always have a moral lurking in their glittery depths.  Sleeping Beauty and Snow White taught us that the secret to feminine allure is hibernation, Beauty and the Beast showed us that looks don’t matter unless you’re the girl, and Hansel and Gretel taught us that we shouldn’t eat other people’s houses.  So what are the morals of Valente’s fairy tales?

First, she’s teaching us to embrace a larger, more colorful world than the tired European Middle Earth we all know and love.  As a white woman raised on a healthy diet of Grimm and Lang, I expect my fairy tales to have castles, villages, inns, stepmothers, witches, and a nice temperate climate.  But in The Night Garden there are djinns and gods, vast deserts, leviathans, fox-faced women and centaur kings.  The cultural references are quiet, but wildly varied: the city of Al-a-Nur is vaguely African and Islamic; a mention of foot-binding puts us in pre-modern China; the mare-goddess belongs on the Mongolian steppe.  It’s disorienting and wonderful.

She’s also teaching us to gently bury our girlhood visions of princesses and stepmothers.  “Maidens stand still, they are lovely statues and all admire them,” says a pirate and former maiden, but “Witches do not stand still. I was neither, but better that I err on the side of witchery, witchery that unlocks towers and empties ships.”  In the Night Garden passes the Bechdel test, as Nadine says, a hundred times over.  It even passes the newly-minted Russo test, which I didn’t even know existed.  Even more rarely, Valente doesn’t feel compelled to beat us into submission by shouting, Look, reader, it’s a Strong Female Character Rejecting Patriarchy.  It’s much more subtle, powerful, and painfully simple: her women are old, ugly, beautiful, married, celibate, violent, magical, and everything else it is possible to be in a fairytale.

Michael Kaluta IllustrationFinally, and maybe most importantly, Valente’s stories tell us that we should listen to the stories of the disempowered—what my dear postcolonial scholars would call subaltern voices.  Her characters are the poor, dispossessed, monstrous, forgotten, and failed.  There’s the orphan girl in some far northern fishing town, scrabbling for food and sleeping in the hulls of half-built boats.  There’s a three-breasted Saint, an enslaved witch, a forgotten prophetess, a deer-footed princess, and a condemned Papess.  The usual heroes—princes, kings, and wizards—are dangerous, ignorant characters who stomp heavy-footed through the stories.  As one king tells his son, “Kings know there is only the Reign, and all things may be committed in its holy name…I have more blood on my hands than you could spill in a lifetime.  I wear it proudly.  It is my crown and my scepter.”

All these ambitions have their price: It takes an effort of concentration to follow all the winding stories and new characters and suddenly changing perspectives.  The book can feel episodic, and there are unfinished threads and little fissures in the logic.  It also takes a certain spirit of adventure; Valente takes you into the untracked fairytale wilderness and leaves you with nothing but a book of matches and a broken compass, without a familiar landmark in sight.  It’s probably good for you.  Because, in the end, In the Night Garden has the kinds of stories I’d like my (strictly imaginary) daughter to read.  I’m eager to unearth the sequel, In the Cities of Coin and Spice.

Valente, Catherynne M. The Orphan’s Tales, Vol. 1: In the Night Garden. New York: Bantam Dell, 2006. Winner of the James Tiptree Jr. Award, 2006; Nominated for the World Fantasy Award

Other Reviews:



  1. You need to stop telling me how good some of these books are. I have things to do and because of horrid circumstances, reading for pleasure is not one of them. WIth that said, I just ordered this too so at least my winter break reading list is looking solid.

  2. Interesting. I’ll add this to my list of books to read in that imaginary future when I have time to read for fun again. Little bit jealous of you right now. 🙂

    1. …I don’t want to brag, but writing a couple thousand words about history in the morning (still my only paying work), and then reading fantasy books all day, is kind of the life.

  3. Sorry for the double post, but your mention of djinn reminded me of another book I haven’t yet had the time to read called The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker. If you ever find yourself casting about for something to read next, I’d happily send you to vet it for me cause it looked interesting… Or at the very least, it looked different than the normal castle/middle earth genre tropes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s