Dreamer’s Pool: The Perilous Business of Being Female in Fantasy

dreamers poolThose who have read Marillier before know the drill: She produces exceptionally readable and endearing fantasy set in the medieval and ancient British Isles, revolving around women, myths, and magic. I adored Daughter of the Forest for its loving recreation of my absolute favorite fairy tale as a kid (the Six Swans).[1] The other Sevenwaters books went by in a blur of kings and curses because I was on vacation and had to get through the entire series before my Mom left with her duffle bag of paperbacks.

Dreamer’s Pool is still about women, magic, and ancient Ireland. So if you liked Sevenwaters, there’s no need to fear that Marillier is now writing about werewolf romances in Prague or artificially intelligent zucchini or something. But in some key ways Dreamer’s Pool is a departure from her previous works, focusing on the lowest rungs of society rather than the ruling family and looking at much wider and more real social ills. Not that help-my-brothers-are-swans isn’t a compelling problem, it’s just not, you know, something that haunts my nightmares.

The story revolves around two tough ex-prisoners with suitably tough, ex-prisoner names: Blackthorn and Grim. Blackthorn is a healer obsessed with vengeance against her princely jailer. Grim is a slightly-mentally-unsound mystery-man imprisoned for god-knows-what and obsessed with protecting Blackthorn. On the day before Blackthorn’s execution a meddling member of the fey arrives and cuts her a deal: He’ll bust her out of prison if she’ll swear to help anyone who asks for it and not seek revenge, for seven years. She agrees.

Blackthorn and Grim flee north and settle into a little cottage on the edge of forest that practically screams Magical Weird Stuff Happens Here. They become entangled with the local prince and his mysteriously awful bride-to-be, and the rest of the story is a quick-moving combination of crime-solving and dealing with their own scarred pasts. Some of it leads to moments of shocking darkness, but this isn’t the sort of story that leaves many wrongs un-righted.

daughter of the forestDreamer’s Pool is exactly the kind of heartfelt but fast-paced fantasy book you need sometimes. If you want an epic showdown between the Chosen One and Ultimate Evil, look elsewhere. If you want a surreal yet cerebral analysis of the human condition, look elsewhere. If you want a twisting and shocking mystery that keeps you guessing until the last page—yeah, still look elsewhere. But if you just want an honest and hardworking sort of story with two lovable main characters, some magic, and some commentary about the perils of being a woman in the ancient past (or, you know, right now), then Dreamer’s Pool is 100% for you.

I don’t want to make it sound like pure cotton-candy—the kind of fantasy book that includes dragons, princesses, daring rescues, and is mostly made of air and artificial dye—because it deals with some surprisingly dark and serious themes. The most blinding theme is also the most chilling: women and the abuses they suffer, and the ways their voices go unheard. Women in Marillier’s world face violence, rape, and a kind of suffocating voiceless-ness. Some of them survive and heal, some of them don’t, but all of them are quite real.

In most ways, the emphasis on women and victimhood makes the book stronger and more unified than it might otherwise be. In other ways…it was like wading through the Fire Swamp, except instead of Rodents of Unusual Size it was Rapes of Unusual Frequency. Now, it wasn’t the kind of casual and chilling rape that exists in George R.R. It’s-All-Historically-Accurate Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire—this isn’t rape as window dressing. Nor is it rape as a way of showing how bad the bad guy is. But it does, sometimes, feel like sexual violence is the primary motivator for most of the female characters. Which is a squicky plot device.[2]

To its great credit, Dreamer’s Pool also spends a lot of time talking about the ways abuse victims are received by their communities–how a woman’s credibility is questioned and her sexual history scrutinized for signs she may have been “asking for it.” But then, bummer alert: One of the villains in the story turns out to be an absolute caricature of the seductive and manipulative serving-woman, using her feminine wiles to climb the social ladder. She even descends to a false rape accusation–an even squickier plot device.

But I still swallowed the whole thing in about two days, and enjoyed almost every minute of it. It moves easily forward, and Blackthorn herself is just the kind of tough-but-lovable character I adore. Marillier hasn’t lost the straightforward charm of her previous works, but she might be delving into darker and more perilous stories. The kind that must be navigated nimbly, to avoid squickiness.[3]

Dreamer’s Pool is available November 4th, 2014.


[1] I also loved Labyrinth. I had two younger brothers, see, and stories where they might vanish and be heroically rescued by me were kind of my thing. In reality, they spent their childhoods ricocheting through the house like gleeful grenades full of mess and noise and action figure battles—never once getting kidnapped by David Bowie–while I hunched over a book in the corner and tsked.

[2] Squicky: That feeling when something happens in a book that’s perfectly plausible but also clichéd, ugly, and kind of makes you sick to your feminist stomach.

[3] If you want medieval almost-fantasy that genuinely portrays the full complexity and depth of women’s lived experiences, Nicola Griffith’s Hild is a book of an entirely different caliber. But then, Hild makes every other medieval fantasy book on the planet look like a cheesy puppet show where you can see the puppeteers bumbling behind the curtain.



  1. I like the sound of this. Is it romance-centric? Based on what you’ve said of the plot it sounds like a high fantasy/drama going down. Also, what’s the fantastical element [if any] like? Magical realism, or more along the lines of elves and dwarves?

    1. I’d say the fantasy is more like…if all the Irish-y Gaelic myths about the fae and magic and druids were true. It’s not really a high fantasy in the Tolkein-ish sense.

      And the romance isn’t really the central focus; Blackthorn and Grim have an enjoyably not-romantic relationship, which I kind of hope stays that way in the rest of the books…

      1. You had me sold at not-romantic 😀 I’ll definitely pick this up. It sounds top notch, and I really want to add more female written epic fantasy to my diet.

  2. But wait! I’m seriously desperate to discuss your point: “She even descends to a false rape accusation–an even squickier plot device.”

    I was so on board with this book as a stand out for discussing victim blaming in a fantasy setting (something I have yet to run across) and then Marillier goes and throws THAT into it. Whether she meant to or not, I felt like she undid a lot of her good work by reinforcing a stereotype that men call upon to discredit some accusations of rape. I understand the role it plays in the plot but I feel like, in a book that had been remarkably subtle in it’s weaving, it was a clunky and too-easy device to call upon. It doesn’t much damage my otherwise glowing enjoyment of the tale but I was slightly disappointed to find that burr. I’m at least glad that someone else also stumbled on it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s